Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Reindeer

I had a lot of ideas in my head of projects I wanted to try out this holiday season, and this is the one that has won out as my favorite so far. My Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Pumpkins were so incredibly popular, that I knew I needed to come up with some new ideas for Christmas…and probably for every season afterward! (Can you say, Chocolate Covered Peeps??? YUM!!!)

Chocolate covered Marshmallow pops with white sprinkles for eyes, a red candy nose and pretzel antlers

I am giddy with excitement at how cute these turned out!!!

Want to make your own?

Here’s what you need:

Large Marshmallows (I prefer Jet-Puffed over the store brand)

Lollipop sticks, popsicle sticks, or pretzel sticks

Ribbon

Melting Chocolate (I prefer the ones you buy at the craft store for their smooth texture)

Cinnamon dots, Hot Tamales or Mike & Ike’s Reds

Small Pretzels

Pearl Sprinkles (or other candies for the eyes)

Foam block

The supplies used to make reideer marshmallow pops - marshmallows on white lollipop sticks, red candies, pretzels and melting chocolate and red ribbon

First, set up your assembly line.

Break the pretzels in half. It was not an easy task to get them all to break properly, so make sure to have plenty on hand. You need two halves for each reindeer’s antlers.

Snip just the ends of the Hot Tamales or Mike & Ike’s, or count out your cinnamon dots. I used the Mike & Ike’s because I’m planning to give these to Cooper’s preschool class, and the cinnamon ones are a little too spicy for him.

red mik and ikes candy spilling out of a box on a metal baking sheet

Put the marshmallows on the stick, and push them into the foam block. This saves you from having to do that with melted chocolate on them. (Since this was only a trial run, I was working with what I had on hand. I’m going to purchase a larger block next trip to the craft store.)

I scored the tops of the marshmallows, hoping that would make it easier to attach the pretzel antlers.

Once your assembly line is set, it’s time to melt your chocolate.

Place chocolate melts or chocolate chips in a microwaveable glass bowl. Microwave on high at 20-30 second intervals, stirring each time until chocolate is just melted, but not too hot.

a marshmallow on a stick being dipped in chocolate

Dip a marshmallow into the chocolate, covering it entirely. Use the backside of a spoon to smooth out the side and top, and to remove any excess. Place it back into the foam block and repeat the process on the next marshmallow.

a chocolate covered marshmallow on a lollipop stick

After about five or six marshmallows, add the pretzel antlers, by gently inserting them into the scored parts of the marshmallows, and hold them for a few seconds to make sure they are secure. This took some practice!

a chocolate covered marshmallow with pretzels in the top for antlers

For the nose and eyes, you can either add them when the chocolate is still wet, or finish the whole batch, then dab some melted chocolate onto each piece and attach it to the marshmallow to make the face. I did it both ways, but decided the second way was easier.

Once they are completely dry, tie a small piece of ribbon around the stick like a scarf.

These would make great treats for neighbors, teachers, classmates or as party favors.Wrap in a plastic treat bag, and relish in the oohs and ahhs as you deliver them to your friends!

Join the Conversation

Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Reindeer

5 Secrets to Dinnertime Sanity

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

About Kristin Maxwell

5 Secrets to Dinnertime Sanity

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment Cancel reply